What it is — Cartilage and Joint Wear
Articular cartilage is the smooth white layer covering the ends of the bones inside a joint. It lets the surfaces glide with less friction than ice on ice and spreads load across the bone. It has no blood vessels and no nerves: that is why it does not hurt directly and, more importantly, why it barely repairs itself.
Wear can be diffuse, as in osteoarthritis, or focal: a localised cartilage defect in one spot, often after a blow or a twist. That distinction drives the treatment. A focal lesion in a young person with the rest of the joint healthy can be repaired; diffuse, generalised wear is managed as osteoarthritis.
Because cartilage does not hurt, symptoms appear once the damage already affects the bone underneath or the joint lining. That explains why wear progresses silently for years, and why what eventually brings patients in is recurrent swelling or pain on loading.
Common symptoms
- Deep joint pain that worsens with weight-bearing and eases with rest
- Intermittent swelling, particularly after prolonged activity
- Grinding, clicking or a sensation of rubbing when moving the joint
- A catching sensation, as if something is getting in the way inside the joint
- Momentary locking when a fragment of cartilage has come loose
- Stiffness after staying in one position
- Progressive loss of range of motion
Why it happens
- Direct trauma or a twist under load, which shears off a fragment of cartilage and creates a focal lesion.
- Sustained overload from high body weight or repeated impact activity.
- Limb malalignment, concentrating the whole load on a small area of the joint surface.
- Untreated previous ligament or meniscal injuries, which alter load distribution.
- Chronic joint instability, subjecting cartilage to repeated shear.
- Osteochondritis dissecans, in which a fragment of bone and cartilage loses its blood supply and separates.
- Age and genetic factors, which reduce cartilage's capacity to maintain itself.
How it is diagnosed
Suspicion arises from the pattern of pain: deep, load-related, with episodes of swelling. The examination looks for effusion, localises pain to the joint line, assesses stability and alignment, and examines the menisci and ligaments, because a cartilage lesion is rarely isolated.
Weight-bearing X-rays assess joint space and alignment, but they do not show cartilage: a normal X-ray does not rule out a chondral lesion. MRI is the reference test, because it defines the depth and extent of the defect, the state of the underlying bone and any associated injuries. That information decides whether the defect is specifically treatable or managed as osteoarthritis.
How we treat it
Treatment without surgery
- Weight control, which directly reduces the load crossing the damaged area with every step.
- Strengthening the muscles around the joint, which absorb part of the load and protect the joint surface.
- Switching to low-impact activity — cycling, swimming, elliptical — while maintaining overall activity levels.
- Anti-inflammatories during episodes of pain and swelling, for limited periods.
- Hyaluronic acid injection in selected cases, to improve lubrication and load tolerance.
- Corticosteroid injection to break an inflammatory flare with effusion, without routine repetition.
- Correcting the underlying mechanical factors: foot orthotics, hip work, review of sporting technique.
When surgery is considered
- Marrow stimulation techniques, such as microfracture, perforate the bone beneath the defect so the marrow forms repair tissue. They work best in small defects in young patients; the resulting tissue is not identical to original cartilage.
- Osteochondral transplantation takes cylinders of bone and cartilage from a non-weight-bearing area and moves them to the defect, providing genuine cartilage. It is useful for lesions of limited size.
- Cultured chondrocyte implantation harvests the patient's own cells, multiplies them in the laboratory and reimplants them. It is reserved for large defects in selected young patients.
- Osteotomy corrects alignment to unload the damaged area, and is often the step that makes any repair technique viable: repairing cartilage without correcting the axis condemns the repair.
- When wear is diffuse and the joint is globally deteriorated, the route is replacement rather than cartilage repair.
What recovery looks like
Recovery after cartilage repair is long and demanding, and this is worth knowing before accepting surgery. The new tissue needs movement to mature but does not tolerate load: the usual pattern is six to eight weeks of partial weight-bearing on crutches combined with passive movement from the first days.
Return to low-impact activity comes around the third or fourth month, and impact sport no earlier than nine to twelve months. The repair tissue continues maturing for more than a year, and loading it too early compromises the final result.
With conservative treatment, pain improvement is usually noticeable six to twelve weeks after seriously starting strengthening and weight control. It is a result that holds as long as the work continues.
When not to wait
- The joint locks or you feel something getting in the way when you move it.
- It swells repeatedly after activity.
- Deep pain on weight-bearing has lasted more than six weeks without improving.
- You had a ligament or meniscal injury and have started getting new pain on loading.
- You have lost range of motion or the joint gives way under load.
- You are young and have been told you have wear: it is worth assessing whether it is focal and treatable.
Frequently asked questions
Does cartilage regenerate?
On its own, essentially no, because it has no blood vessels to carry repair cells. Surgical techniques can fill the defect with repair tissue that works, but it is not identical to original cartilage. That is why the realistic goal is protecting the cartilage you still have, not recovering what is lost.
Do collagen, glucosamine or chondroitin help?
They do not regenerate cartilage. The evidence for pain relief is weak and the results modest and inconsistent between studies. They are rarely harmful, but they should not take the place of what does have demonstrated effect: weight control, muscle strengthening and staying active.
What is the difference between this and osteoarthritis?
They are two points on the same story. Focal wear is a localised defect with the rest of the joint healthy, and in young patients it can be repaired. Osteoarthritis is diffuse deterioration of the whole joint, involving bone, synovial lining and menisci, and is managed with a different approach.
Does it show on an X-ray?
Not directly: X-rays show bone, not cartilage. What is visible is narrowing of the space between the bones, which is an indirect and late sign. A normal X-ray does not rule out a cartilage lesion, which is why MRI is used when suspicion is high.
Can I keep exercising?
Yes, and it is part of the treatment. What matters is changing the type: swapping impact for cycling, swimming or the elliptical, and adding strength work for the muscles around the joint. Stopping movement weakens that muscle and ends up increasing the load the damaged cartilage receives.
This page is general patient information, reviewed by Dr. Alvaro Quesada Chaves. It does not replace a medical consultation: every case changes with age, activity level and what the physical exam and imaging show.